CPG LearnROI & decision-makingUpdated

Is my Charizard worth grading? An honest guide by era

CPG 51 7141

9
Min read
Timeline of commonly graded Charizard cards from 1999 Base Set to the 2023-2024 Scarlet & Violet ex cards, with what usually decides whether each is worth grading

Is your Charizard a PSA 10 candidate or a PSA 8?

Upload four photos and the scan measures front and back centering and flags corner, edge and holo surface issues, so you know where your Charizard stands before you pay to grade it.

First scan free, no credit card needed. Then credit packs from about 50¢ a scan. See a sample report

Check my Charizard →
On this page · 10 sections
  1. 01 Quick answer by era
  2. 02 What decides it for any Charizard
  3. 03 1999 Base Set Charizard
  4. 04 Shining Charizard (Neo Destiny, 2002)
  5. 05 Hidden Fates Shiny Charizard GX (2019)
  6. 06 Champion's Path Charizard VMAX (2020)
  7. 07 Charizard ex: 151, Obsidian Flames, Paldean Fates
  8. 08 Worked example: the grading sum
  9. 09 Why a PSA 10 Charizard is hard
  10. 10 Your Charizard checklist

Is your Charizard worth grading? It depends far more on which Charizard you have than on the name. A clean 1999 Base Set Charizard is almost always worth sending to PSA. Many modern Charizard ex cards sell raw for less than PSA's $39.99 Value fee, so grading them only pays when they come back a PSA 10.

This guide goes era by era through the Charizard cards people most often ask about, what decides each one, and the sum to run before you pay. We don't quote live prices: Charizard prices move fast, so every number here is illustrative and you should check recent sold prices for your exact card.

Is my Charizard worth grading? Quick answer by era

  • 1999 Base Set Charizard: authenticity and condition decide it. Most clean, genuine copies are worth grading.
  • 2002 Shining Charizard (Neo Destiny): usually worth grading if clean.
  • 2019 Hidden Fates Shiny Charizard GX: check centering and the holo surface first.
  • 2020 Champion's Path Charizard VMAX: heavily graded, so the PSA 10 premium decides it.
  • 2023-24 Charizard ex (151, Obsidian Flames, Paldean Fates): grade the Special Illustration Rares only if they look gem mint.

What decides it for any Charizard

  1. The exact card and variant. Set, card number, edition and print all change the value. A 1st Edition and an Unlimited Base Set Charizard are different cards as far as price goes.
  2. The price gap between grades. Pull 90-day sold prices for raw, PSA 8, PSA 9 and PSA 10 (eBay sold listings plus PSA's own price data). For a lot of modern cards the PSA 9 price is close to raw, which means you're only grading for a 10.
  3. The fee for that value. PSA prices tiers by declared value: Value is $39.99 for cards up to $500, Standard $59.99 up to $1,000, Priority $79.99 up to $1,500, and higher tiers above that (as listed in November 2026). Add shipping both ways and insurance.
  4. Your card's condition. Centering, corners, edges and surface. The weakest of the four sets the ceiling. The PSA grading scale guide shows what each grade allows.

1999 Base Set Charizard

The 1999 Base Set holo Charizard (4/102) comes in three main English versions: 1st Edition, Shadowless and Unlimited. All three are valuable enough that even mid grades usually sell well above the cost of grading, so for most clean, genuine copies the question isn't whether to grade but which PSA tier the value puts you in. Many copies will be worth more than the $500 limit of PSA's Value tier.

Two things matter most. First, authenticity: Base Set Charizard is one of the most counterfeited cards there is, and a PSA slab settles the question for any future buyer. Run the home checks for fake Pokemon cards before you submit. Second, condition: centering on vintage prints varies a lot, and the dark back shows edge wear quickly. Check that the grade you realistically expect, often in the PSA 5-8 range for played copies, still beats the raw price plus the fee.

Shining Charizard (Neo Destiny, 2002)

Shining Charizard (107/105) is from Neo Destiny, released in 2002, and exists in 1st Edition and Unlimited. It's a vintage holo with steady demand, so clean copies are usually worth grading. As with Base Set, check centering on both axes and look hard at the back edges and corners, where whitening shows first on the dark blue border. Our whitening guide shows what to look for.

Hidden Fates Shiny Charizard GX (2019)

The Shiny Charizard GX (SV49/SV94) from Hidden Fates was printed in large numbers, so the decision comes down to the gap between a PSA 9 and a PSA 10 for that card at the time you check. The shiny holo surface picks up fine scratches easily. Before you pay, measure the centering and tilt the card under a lamp to check the holo. Our holo scratch guide explains the raking-light check.

Champion's Path Charizard VMAX (2020)

Champion's Path was one of the most hyped sets of 2020, and its Charizard cards (the Charizard V, Charizard VMAX and the secret rare Charizard VMAX that most collectors were chasing) have been graded in large numbers. When a card has a big PSA 10 population, a PSA 9 often sells for not much more than a raw copy. That makes it a PSA 10-or-nothing decision: only send a copy where centering is inside 55/45 on the front and the corners, edges and surface are clean.

Charizard ex: 151, Obsidian Flames, Paldean Fates (2023-24)

Scarlet & Violet brought several Charizard ex cards: the Charizard ex in 151 (September 2023), the Tera Charizard ex in Obsidian Flames (August 2023) and the shiny Charizard ex in Paldean Fates (January 2024). Each set has a regular ex, higher-rarity versions, and a Special Illustration Rare, which is usually the one with real value.

  • Regular and full-art Charizard ex: often sell raw for less than the grading fee. Grading rarely pays unless you're keeping the card.
  • Special Illustration Rares: worth considering, but only for copies that look gem mint. The textured surface shows scratches and print lines, and the PSA 9 price is often not far above raw.

These cards are modern pack pulls, so the condition problems are mostly factory ones: centering, edge chipping from the cut, and surface print lines. Measure centering first; it's the quickest way to rule a card out. Here's how to measure it.

Worked example: the grading sum

Here's the sum for an illustrative modern Charizard ex Special Illustration Rare. The prices are made up to show the method. Put in real sold prices for your card.

OutcomeSold price (illustrative)Your estimated chanceWeighted value
PSA 10$30030%$90
PSA 9$12050%$60
PSA 8$7520%$15
Expected sale price$165
Less all-in cost (PSA Value fee, shipping, insurance)-$60
Expected net$105
Bar chart of an illustrative expected-value calculation: probability-weighted PSA 10, 9 and 8 sale prices stacked against the raw value plus all-in grading cost
Illustrative numbers: an expected sale of $165 less a $60 all-in cost leaves $105, or $45 more than selling the card raw for $60.

If the raw card sells for $60, grading is worth +$45 on average. But it leans on that 30% chance of a PSA 10. Drop it to 15% (with PSA 9 at 65%) and the expected sale falls to $138, the expected net to $78, and the gain over raw to $18. That's not worth tying the card up for months.

Our rule of thumb is to submit only when the expected sale is at least 3x the all-in cost and beats raw plus the cost. Here, $165 is just short of $180, so it's borderline. The full method is in should I grade my Pokemon card?

Why a PSA 10 Charizard is hard to get

  • Holo and textured surfaces. Fine hairlines that are invisible flat-on show up when the card is tilted under a lamp. How scratches affect the grade.
  • Edge and corner whitening. The dark blue Pokemon back shows the lightest wear. PSA's written standard wants four perfectly sharp corners for a 10. How whitening affects the grade.
  • Centering. PSA 10 needs about 55/45 or better on the front and 75/25 on the back. Plenty of pack-fresh cards miss on one axis.

Your Charizard checklist

  1. Identify the exact set, card number and variant.
  2. For vintage, run the authenticity checks before anything else.
  3. Pull 90-day sold prices for raw, PSA 8, PSA 9 and PSA 10.
  4. Work out the all-in cost for the PSA tier that matches the card's value.
  5. Check centering, corners, edges and surface, and be honest about the likely grade.
  6. Run the sum and apply the 3x rule. If it's close, look again before paying.

Want a second opinion on the condition part? A pre-grade measures centering from your photos and marks what it finds, and this photo guide shows how to shoot a holo so the checks are reliable. You can also look at a sample report first.

Frequently asked questions

Should I grade my 1999 Base Set Charizard?

Usually yes, if it's genuine and reasonably clean. Graded copies tend to sell well above raw at most grades, and the slab settles authenticity, which matters because Base Set Charizard is one of the most faked cards. Its value will often put it above PSA's $500 Value limit, so price the sum with the right tier.

Is a modern Charizard ex worth grading?

Usually only the Special Illustration Rares, and only copies that look gem mint. Many regular and full-art Charizard ex cards sell raw for less than PSA's $39.99 Value fee, so a PSA 9 rarely pays for itself.

Why is it hard to get a PSA 10 Charizard?

Holo and textured surfaces show hairline scratches, the dark Pokemon back shows whitening at the edges, and centering varies from print to print. Any one of those can keep a card out of PSA 10.

How much is a PSA 10 Charizard worth?

It depends entirely on the card. A 1999 Base Set Charizard in PSA 10 is a five-figure card or more, while modern Charizard ex PSA 10s sell for far less. Check recent sold listings or PSA's price data for your exact card and variant.

Should I grade Champion's Path Charizard?

Only a copy you're confident is a PSA 10 candidate. It has been graded in large numbers, so the price gap between PSA 9 and PSA 10 decides whether grading pays. Check centering and the holo surface before you submit.

Can PSA tell if my Charizard is fake?

Yes. PSA authenticates every card before grading and won't grade one of questionable authenticity. Run the home checks first so you don't pay to submit a fake.

First scan free

Is your Charizard a PSA 10 candidate or a PSA 8?

Upload four photos and the scan measures front and back centering and flags corner, edge and holo surface issues, so you know where your Charizard stands before you pay to grade it.

  • Front and back centering vs PSA's limits
  • Corner, edge and surface marks, boxed
  • Grade range + submit / borderline / skip

First scan free, no credit card needed. Then credit packs from about 50¢ a scan. A pre-grade is an estimate, not a guaranteed grade.

Keep reading

Is My Charizard Worth Grading? By-Era Guide + Fee Maths